فصلنامه روابط خارجی

فصلنامه روابط خارجی

راهبرد مصون‌سازی عربستان در مواجهه با آمریکا و چین و تأثیر آن بر منافع ملی ایران

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان
1 دانشیار گروه روابط بین‌الملل، دانشکده حقوق و علوم سیاسی، دانشگاه خوارزمی، تهران، ایران
2 پژوهشگر پسادکتری روابط بین‌الملل، دانشکده حقوق و علوم سیاسی، دانشگاه خوارزمی، تهران، ایران
چکیده
دهه اخیر رویکرد تعامل بین چین و ایالات‌متحده آمریکا به رقابت تبدیل‌شده است. در عصر رقابت و شکاف دو قدرت مذکور، بسیاری از دولت‌ها اقدام به باز تنظیم سیاست خارجی خود نموده‌اند. در این میان نقش سنتی عربستان سعودی به‌عنوان بازوی امنیتی و تأمین‌کننده انرژی غرب، به دلیل سیاست «چرخش به آسیا» آمریکا، ظهور اقتصادی چین و تشدید رقابت چین و آمریکا در حال تغییر است. هدف این مقاله تبیین راهبرد عربستان در مواجهه با رقابت چین و آمریکا است و به روش             تحلیلی-تبیینی به این پرسش پاسخ داده که عربستان سعودی چگونه در وضعیت عدم اطمینان، رقابت و شکاف میان چین و آمریکا زمینه همکاری با آن دو را فراهم نموده و این رویکرد چه تأثیری بر منافع ملی ایران خواهد داشت؟ مفروض پژوهش بر این است که عربستان سعودی با درک تغییر توانمندی و آرایش جدید مؤلفه‌های نظم بین‌المللی، سیاست خارجی خود را بر مبنای راهبرد مصون‌سازی بازتنظیم نموده تا ضمن بهره‌مندی از مزایای روابط با چین و آمریکا، امکان کاهش مدیریت ریسک‌های سیاسی و اقتصادی با این دو بازیگر قدرتمند و قدرت‌های منطقه‌ای از جمله ایران را فراهم آورد. یافته­های پژوهش بر چگونگی تنظیم دقیق‌تر مناسبات سیاسی و اقتصادی با عربستان در بستر رویکرد مصون‌سازی این کشور تأکید دارد.
کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات


عنوان مقاله English

Saudi Arabia's Hedging Strategy in facing with US and China and its impact on Iran's national interests

نویسندگان English

Seyed Saeed Mirtorabi 1
Mohsen Keshvarian azad 2
1 Associate Professor in International Relations, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Kharazmi University, Tehran, Iran
2 Postdoctoral Researcher in International Relations, Department of International Relations, Kharazmi University, Tehran, Iran
چکیده English

In the last decade, the approach of engagement between China and the United States has turned into competition. In the era of competition and the gap between the two powers, many governments have taken steps to reorganize their foreign policies. Meanwhile, the traditional role of Saudi Arabia as the security arm and energy supplier for the West is changing due to the US “pivot to Asia” policy, the economic rise of China, and the intensification of Sino-US competition. This article aims to explain Saudi Arabia's strategy in the face of competition between China and the United States, and to answer the question in an analytical-explanatory Method, How has Saudi Arabia provided the basis for cooperation with China and the United States in a situation of uncertainty, competition, and gap between Two Powers, and what impact will this approach have on Iran's national interests? in response, it is assumed that Saudi Arabia, realizing the change in capabilities and the new arrangement of the components of the international order, has readjusted its foreign policy based on the Hedging Strategy in order to use from the benefits of relations with China and the United States, providing the possibility of reducing the management of political and economic risks with these two powerful actors and regional powers, including Iran.
Theoretical Framework: This article uses the Hedging Strategy. This theory is rooted in the realist theory of international relations and accepts the main principles of realist theory, such as anarchy, no formal central authority, uncertainty and seeks to reduce foreign policy risk in a realist world. The Hedging Strategy is used by middle-power states in a decentralized unipolar system, in which the hegemon’s ability to impose power is declining. The adoption of such a strategy by smaller states is described as a kind of soft balance, involving interaction in bilateral relations and strengthening economic and political interactions with two rival regional powers. This strategy emphasizes engagement and integration mechanisms on the one hand and balancing on the other. A state that adopts this strategy cooperates with a strong and emerging state to prevent threats and vulnerabilities. The Middle and smaller government's Hedging strategy manifests itself in three forms: weak cooperation, moderate cooperation, and strong cooperation. Saudi Arabia has attempted to regulate its foreign relations with the United States and China at these three levels.
Discussion: Within the framework of the Hedging Strategy, Saudi Arabia's foreign policy has been adjusted in such a way that the country is less harmed by the gap and competition between great powers. Cooperation in three dimensions; weak, moderate and strong cooperation has been evident in various areas between China and the United States. Saudi Arabia adopted this strategy because it faces several strategic dilemmas in the future as the US hegemonic role in the West Asian region declines; on the one hand, Saudi Arabia considers the alliance with the US vital for its defense and regional stability, but it is concerned about the future of US security commitments to West Asian countries. On the other hand, China has been Saudi Arabia’s number one trading partner in the past decade, which Saudi Arabia considers important for its economic prosperity.
The United States remains a reliable ally and a strong partner in the security-military field; according to Saudi Arabia, there is currently no alternative to the United States in West Asia from a military perspective, and the United States has strong security and arms deals with Saudi Arabia. In fact, the strong security-military ties of the past indicate that the security relations between Saudi Arabia and the United States will continue, and in the context of new arms deals, the issue of civilian nuclear knowledge transfer and the space cooperation agreement has become apparent. Despite Saudi Arabia’s strong military cooperation with the United States, Riyadh has sought to increase its military and economic power and play a more active regional role by strengthening regional and international alliances. In parallel with strong military cooperation with the United States, Saudi Arabia’s weak and moderate cooperation with China is progressing at the political-security level, and moderate cooperation in the energy sector has been strengthened; Saudi Arabia’s cooperation with the United States in the energy sector has been reduced to a moderate and weak level, while cooperation with China has been maintained at a moderate level and is likely to enter the level of strong cooperation. The weakening of the dollar through the Petroyuan and direct investment and financing have also been cited as other examples of moderate cooperation between Saudi Arabia and China. Saudi Arabia’s hedging strategy with China and the United States has a transitory effect on Iran’s regional policies. By avoiding a dual geopolitical strategy, Saudi Arabia advances its strategic interests by pursuing good relations with China and the United States in order to ensure its future political and security stability and reduce the risk of damage from a confrontational policy with Iran. Saudi Arabia’s coherent plan, in the form of an approach of hedging with the two great powers, increases its economic and military capabilities in the region and avoids direct confrontation with them, thereby managing the economic supply chain and security order of the region. Saudi Arabia also seeks to manage its relations with Iran by expanding its relations with China. It improves its position in China’s foreign policy through diversification of energy and investment policies and moderates the challenges of its relations with Iran through China.
Conclusion: Saudi Arabia has adopted a Hedging Strategy in its foreign policy to regulate its foreign policy with China and the United States, thereby using from the benefits of bilateral relations and, by compromising between cooperative and antagonistic mechanisms and observing the principle of the middle ground, covering its possible risks and vulnerabilities to the two great powers. Saudi Arabia’s Hedging strategy toward the US and China is to maximize the political and economic returns from cooperation with both sides and reduce long-term risks to economic and political security without severing coherent and beneficial relations with these two actors and other global and regional actors. In addition to regulating Saudi Arabia’s relations with China and the US, Hedging also affects relations with other actors and regulates relations with other actors within that framework. Security-military cooperation with the United States will remain strong and at this level, but at the economic level (energy), cooperation has gone from strong to moderate and weak. This situation allows Saudi Arabia to use economic opportunities (China) while using sustainable and vital security partnerships (US). Saudi Arabia, along with the role of the United States, is paying attention to China's active role in the form of economic interaction, active diplomacy, and a greater role in resolving regional conflicts, and through this, it influences the development of Iran's political, security, and economic relations with China in the region.

کلیدواژه‌ها English

Saudi Arabia
China
United States of America
Hedging Strategy
Iran
  • Al-Tamimi, N(2021). China and Saudi Arabia: from enmity to strategic hedging. In Routledge Handbook on China–Middle East Relations (pp. 137-154). Routledge.‌
  • Alterman, Jon B(2022). What Did Saudi Arabia Just Do, Centre for Strategic and International Studies. Available at: https://www.csis.org/analysis/what-did-saudi-arabia-just-do, Guol, Julia & Scita.
  • Amadeo, k(2022). What is the Petrodollar?, The Balance. Available at: https://www.thebalancemoney.com/what-is-a-petrodollar-3306358#:~:text=In%201979%2C%20the%20United%20States%20and%20Saudi%20Arabia,These%20companies%20improve%20Saudi%20infrastructure%20through%20technology%20transfer, 2022/ 06/04.
  • Anwar, D. F (2023). Indonesia's hedging plus policy in the face of China's rise and the US-China rivalry in the Indo-Pacific region. In Navigating International Order Transition in the Indo-Pacific (pp. 125-151). Routledge.‌
  • Araeshi, F(2022). Chinese-Saudi ties important for development of Middle East. China Daily, Available at: https://global.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202212/08/WS639115b8a31057c47eba335c.html, 2022/12/08.
  • Asif, Y, (2024). Saudi Arabia, US working on ‘history making agreement:’ US ambassador in Riyadh. Alarabiya News, Available at: https://english.alarabiya.net/News/gulf/2024/08/26/saudi-arabia-us-working-on-history-making-agreement-us-ambassador-in-riyadh, 2024/08/26.
  • Atlantic Council(2022). What Xi Jinping’s Saudi Arabia visit means for the Middle East. Available at: https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/new-atlanticist/what-xi-jinpings-saudi-arabia-visit-means-for-the-middle-east/, 2022/12/9.
  • Bagheri, A(2022). China-Saudi Arabia missile cooperation. Middle east political and economic institute, Available at: https://mepei.com/china-saudi-arabia-missile-cooperation.
  • Baizidi, R., & Mirtorabi, S. (2024) The System of Sanctionism and the Political Economy of Sanctions in U.S. Domestic and Foreign Policy: An Analysis of the Effectiveness and Challenges of U.S. Sanctionism. Volume 16, Issue 2, Serial Number 62. Pp. Pages 29-62.
  • Bronson, R(2006). Thicker than oil: America's uneasy partnership with Saudi Arabia. Oxford University Press.‌
  • Cengiz, S(2020). Saudi foreign policy towards China in the Post-Arab uprisings era: a neo-classical realist approach. Asian Journal of Middle Eastern and Islamic Studies, 14(1), 51-67.‌
  • Divya, A(2023). Will China Replace the US As Saudi Arabia’s Main Ally?. The Diplomat, Available at: com/2024/06/will-china-replace-the-us-as-saudi-arabias-main-ally/, 2023/06/12.
  • EIA(2023). China Country Analysis Brief. Available at: https://www.eia.gov/international/content/analysis/countries_long/China/pdf/china-2023.pdf,.
  • El-Dessouki, A., & Mansour, O. R(2023). Small states and strategic hedging: the United Arab Emirates’ policy towards Iran. Review of Economics and Political Science, 8(5), 394-407.‌
  • Fulton, J(2020a). China in the Persian Gulf: Hedging under the US umbrella. In Routledge Handbook of Persian Gulf Politics (pp. 492-505). Routledge.‌
  • Fulton, J(2020b). China-Saudi Arabia Relations Through the ‘1+ 2+ 3’Cooperation Pattern. Asian Journal of Middle Eastern and Islamic Studies, 14(4), 516-527.
  • Garlick, J., & Havlová, R(2020). China’s “Belt and Road” economic diplomacy in the persian gulf: Strategic Hedging amidst Saudi–Iranian Regional Rivalry. Journal of Current Chinese Affairs, 49(1), 82-105.‌
  • Ghalkhanbaz, K., Yazdani, E. and Ebrahimi, S. (2023). U.S.-China Strategic Competition and its Impact on US Indo-Pacific Policy: Strategic Lessons for the Islamic Republic of Iran. Foreign Relations, 15(3), 28-56. doi: 10.22034/fr.2024.428449.1468.
  • Gindarsah, I(2016). Strategic hedging in Indonesia’s defense diplomacy. Defense & Security Analysis, 32(4), 336-353.‌
  • Goh, E(2005). Meeting the China challenge: The US in Southeast Asian regional security strategies.‌
  • Gresh,A(2011). Oil Lubricates Trade and Mutual Influence; China and Saudi Arabia: Just Good Friends. Le Monde, 2011/01/10.
  • Guzansky, Y, & Galia L(2020). Saudi Arabia-China relations: A brave friendship or useful leverage?. In Research Forum. Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/346023952_Saudi_ArabiaChina_Relations_A_Brave_Friendship_or_Useful_Leverage.
  • Hamdi, S., & Salman, M(2020). The hedging strategy of small Arab gulf states. Asian Politics & Policy, 12(2), 127-152.‌
  • Heidari, M. (2022). The Reasons for the Expansion of Foreign Relations between Saudi Arabia and China. Iranian Research letter of International Politics, 11(1), 117-142. doi: 10.22067/irlip.2022.21420.0
  • Helmore, E(2022). Saudi Arabia and UAE Leaders ‘Decline Calls with Biden’ Amid Fears of Oil Price Hike. The Guardian, Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/mar/09/saudi-arabia-and-uae-leaders-decline-calls-with-biden-amid-fears-of-oil-price-spike,2022/03/09.
  • Jacopo(2020). China’s Persian Gulf strategy: Keep Tehran and Riyadh content. Atlantic Council, Available at: https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/menasource/chinas-persian-gulf-strategy-keep-tehran-and-riyadh-content.2022/10/06.
  • Jamshidi, M. and Yazdanshenas, Z. (2022). Economic diplomacy and China's strategy in regulating relations with Iran and Saudi Arabia. Strategic Studies of public policy, 12(44), 112-126. doi: 10.22034/sspp.2022.699883.
  • Jones, D. M., & Jenne, N(2022). Hedging and grand strategy in Southeast Asian foreign policy. International Relations of the Asia-Pacific, 22(2), 205-235.‌
  • Kheel, R(2022). Oil Dispute Prompts Call to Remove US from Saudi Arabia, UAE.com, Available at: https://www.military.com/daily-news/2022/10/06/oil-dispute-prompts-call-remove-us-troops-saudi-arabia-uae.html, 2022/10/06.
  • Koga, K(2018). The concept of “hedging” revisited: the case of Japan's foreign policy strategy in East Asia's power shift. International Studies Review, 20(4), 633-660.‌
  • Kouleas, J. A(2023). Saudi Arabian Foreign Policy and Hedging: Playing its Cards Right.
  • Lim, D. J., & Cooper, Z(2015). Reassessing hedging: The logic of alignment in East Asia. Security Studies, 24(4), 696-727.‌
  • Lin, Q(2024). The Achievements and Influence of the 10th Ministerial Meeting of China-Arab States Cooperation Forum. Middle east political and economic institute, Available at: https://mepei.com/the-achievements-and-influence-of-the-10th-ministerial-meeting-of-china-arab-states-cooperation-forum/, 2024/07/14.
  • Liptak, K(2023). Saudi Arabia Looks for Security Assurances from US as Condition for Normalizing Ties with Israel. Reuters, Available at: https://www.cnn.com/2023/03/10/middleeast/saudi-israel-normalization-conditionsintl/index.html.
  • Lopez, C. Todd(2019). Esper: Operation Sentinel Prevents Escalation of Middle East Waterways Conflic.S. Department of Defense, Available at: https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/1915650/esper-operation-sentinel-prevents-escalation-of-middle-east-waterways-conflict/, 2019/06/24.
  • Mehmetcik, H(2015). If You Are Not Big Enough, Pick a Strategy: Bandwagoning, Balancing, Hedging. International Association for Political Science Students, Available at: http://www. iapss. org/2015/04/29/if-you-are-not-big-enough-pick-a-strategbandwagoningbalancing-hedging.‌
  • Mohammad sharifi, M. and Hazrati Razlighi, M. A. (2024). International Order Transition; Saudi Arabia's Economic Strategy And Its Consequences On The Islamic Republic of Iran. Foreign Relations, 16(3), 119-146. doi: 10.22034/fr.2024.432518.1477.
  • Rahimi, R. and Sazmand, B. (2024). Analysis of China's mediation in Iran-Saudi relations in 2023. Foreign Relations, 15(4), 125-148. doi: 10.22034/fr.2024.409983.1425.
  • Sadat Alvand, M (2024). China's Policy towards Iran and Saudi Arabia: Continuity in Balance and Strategic Hedging, Middle East Studies Quarterly, Volume:31 Issue: 1.
  • Salameh, M. T. B(2024). Kuwait's Hedging Strategy Toward Iran and Saudi Arabia. Middle East Quarterly.
  • Salami Zavareh,M & Fallahi Barzoki, M(2018). China’s Energy Security: I.R. Iran and Saudi Arabia’s Role in China’s Energy Diplomacy, Iranian Economic Review, Volume 22, Issue 3 – Serial, Number 3.
  • Samaan, J. L(2022). Arab Gulf States in the Indo-Pacific: The limits of ambiguous hedging strategies. In Indo-Pacific Strategies (pp. 198-215). Routledge.‌
  • Shambaugh D)2007(.China and the US: To Hedge or Engage. YaleGlobal Online. 2007/04/11.
  • Smith, N. R(2018). Strategic hedging by smaller powers: what can neoclassical realism add?. Re-Appraising Neoclassical Realism, London School of Economics, 29 November 2018.‌
  • Suorsa, O(2017). Maintaining a small state’s strategic space: Omnidirectional hedging. International Studies Association Hong Kong, 10, 183.‌
  • Tessman, B., & Wolfe, W(2011). Great powers and strategic hedging: The case of Chinese energy security strategy. International Studies Review, 13(2), 214-240.
  • Trading Economics(2023). China Imports from Saudi Arabia of Crude Oil. Available at: https://tradingeconomics.com/china/imports/saudi-arabia/crude-oil-petroleum-bituminous-minerals.
  • Turak, N(2022). Biden Administration Asked Saudi Arabia to Postpone Opec Decision by a Month. Saudi Says, CNBC, Available at: https://www.cnbc.com/2022/10/13/biden-admin-asked-saudi-arabia-to-postpone-opec-cut-by-a-month-saudis-say.html, 2022/10/13.
  • S. Department of State(2024). The United States and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Sign Framework Agreement for Space Cooperation. Available at: https://www.state.gov/the-united-states-and-the-kingdom-of-saudi-arabia-sign-framework-agreement-for-space-cooperation/, 2024/06/16.
  • Waltz K(1979). Theory of international politics/Kenneth N. Waltz.–Michigan.‌
  • Waltz, K. N. (2010). Theory of international politics. Waveland Press.‌
  • Wilkins, T(2023). Middle power hedging in the era of security/economic disconnect: Australia, Japan, and the ‘Special Strategic Partnership’. International Relations of the Asia-Pacific, 23(1), 93-127.‌
  • Zieff, A(2022). The U.S. Shale Re The U.S. Shale Revolution, Fordham Research Commons. Available at: https://research.library.fordham.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1077&contextr=international_senior, 2020/05/21.